I like crafting, collecting and breeding.
I love games with collectibles for achievements, hi scores and exploration especially! I just started neopets again (can't believe I've had that account for 11 years!) and found that a lot of the stuff I've collected before are ultra rare. I hope that's a good thing. I'm still hoarding plushies and such.
I like breeding games where I can breed for beauty or fighting, but mostly beauty, lol. I followed a link to Pony Island, but I'm a little so (or just a little lazy) and can't figure it out. I used to play a game called A tale in the desert (atitd) that allowed me to find and breed colorful beetles. Later, you could design firework shows or breed the best growing flax.
Crafting, I just love in general. I like to be a tradesperson and specialize in something cool and sell to other players.
What about you guys?